Today I'd like to touch on a story I read out of New Jersey. It's a strong belief of mine that teaching children religious values is borderline child abuse, however this story steps beyond that line. Stories like this are emerging with ever increasing regularity, and it seems that each time the parents in question are almost striving to set the proverbial bar on "crazy" even higher. This woman, however, is apparently not crazy. After psychiatric testing, she was deemed competent to stand trial. Devout, yes - psychotic, no. I wonder parents in other cases like this would test.
For a brief recap of the story itself, a New Jersey woman named Estelle Walker moved into a church retreat cabin with her five children. Her reason for doing so at the time was to escape her estranged husband's alleged alcoholism. She was broke, and unemployed. They stayed there for about one year, and for the last three months that they were in the cabin she apparently made no attempt to feed the kids. They would go days at a time without eating - the longest streak being eleven straight days. Walker said that "God would provide" them with food. By the time the police were called in the kids "were so malnourished they had difficulty talking." This was three years ago, and Walker's trial is set to resume on Tuesday.
Most people who read this article will see it at face value; one crazy lady neglecting her kids because of her blind, irrational faith. The religious people I know would never do this, they're intelligent, (sometimes even rational :D ) human beings. In my opinion, however, this article cannot be taken at face value. This is one of many radical fundamentalists, people who take the idea of faith or religion entirely too far, and they do so while riding on the backs of the moderates. She'll use her faith as a shield, and "God as her defense," and I can guarantee you right now - there will be other fundamentalists who will stand up for her, other religious people who see her plight as admirable.
In my opinion, she should be locked away. Throw away the key and never look back. After all, God will provide her with all the food and company she needs, right?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I am somewhat curious as to what your idea of right and wrong is, being that you are an atheist(and don't take that to be a smug rhetorical question!).
ReplyDeleteWhile going through your older posts I decided to see what had become of this mother of the year candidate. She got 8 years for nearly starving her kids to death waiting for divine intervention. She would be eligible for parole in about 33 months from March 2010.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2010/03/mother_convicted_of_starving_h.html
What I find amusing is that the judge used the words of the Bible to slam her religiotic claims. Score one for the judiciary.
This woman was a good friend of mine. I spoke with her many times whiles she was in prison, the first time. Everyone I know that had been friends with her and attended the same church in NO way believes that what she did was right or sane. Yes, we have a strong faith that our God will provide but would never make such an insane decision to not take care of our children. So before you put us all in her category know we do NOT condone what Estelle has done. We in no way believe that she is sane. I don't know how the courts found her competent. She needs serious help and I am hoping her eyes would be opened to her outrageous beliefs and what she has done. We continue to love her and pray for her.
ReplyDelete